SHAFTSBURY BARRACKS/DUI - DEATH RESULTING/TOWN OF RUPERT

STATE OF VERMONT

DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY

VERMONT STATE POLICE

NEWS RELEASE

MOTOR VEHICLE CRASH

CASE#: 26B3001843                   

RANK/TROOPER FULL NAME: SGT Justin Walker & Trooper Craig Negrin

STATION: Shaftsbury Barracks        

CONTACT#: 802-442-5421

DATE/TIME: 04/18/26 @ 2025 hours

STREET: Suncrest Road

TOWN: Rupert

LANDMARK AND/OR CROSS STREETS: N/A

INTERSTATE MILE MARKER: N/A

WEATHER:     Warm, clear

ROAD CONDITIONS: dry

VEHICLE #1

OPERATOR: Ellsworth A. Reed

AGE: 33      

SEAT BELT? Y

CITY, STATE OF RESIDENCE: West Pawlet, VT

VEHICLE YEAR: 2025

VEHICLE MAKE: CF Moto

VEHICLE MODEL: 1000 XL

DAMAGE TO VEHICLE #1: Extensive damage to entire unit

INJURIES: Yes.

HOSPITAL: Albany Medical, & Rutland Regional Medical Center

SUMMARY OF CRASH:

On 04/18/26 at approximately 2025 hours Vermont State Police were dispatched to a reported ATV crash on Suncrest Road in Rupert. It was reported there were serious injuries involved.

Troopers arrived on scene as rescue and fire personnel on scene were working to extricate one of the occupants of the vehicle. The vehicle was identified as a CF Moto 1000 XL and had rolled over an embankment after leaving the roadway and striking several trees.

While on scene, Troopers began to investigate the incident. The investigation determined there were 5 total occupants, 2 of which were airlifted to Albany Medical center for serious injuries, while a 3rd went to Rutland Regional Medical Center. A 4th passenger died of his injuries on scene during extrication. The deceased passenger's identity is being withheld pending notification of next of kin.

During investigation, Troopers suspected the operator, Ellsworth Reed, to be under the influence of intoxicants. Reed was ultimately taken into custody for suspicion of DUI. Reed was later charged with DUI with death resulting and remanded to the Marble Valley Correctional Facility for lack of $5,000 bail. Additionally, Reed was issued conditions of release to appear in Bennington County Superior Court, Criminal Division on 04/20/2026 at 1230 hours. These conditions and bail were imposed by the Honorable Judge John Valente.

This investigation is still ongoing.

_______

LODGED - Yes  LOCATION: Marble Valley Correctional Facility

BAIL: $5,000

MUG SHOT: N

COURT ACTION: Y

COURT: Bennington Criminal Court

COURT DATE/TIME: 04/20/2026 @ 1230 hours  

*Please note: court date and time are subject to change at the discretion of the court. Please call the criminal court clerk to confirm arraignment time.

Sergeant Justin Walker

Patrol Commander

Vermont State Police 

Troop B - Shaftsbury

96 Airport Rd

Shaftsbury, VT 05262

802-442-5421

Berlin Barracks // Directed Patrol

VSP News Release-Incident

 

STATE OF VERMONT

DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY

VERMONT STATE POLICE

 

NEWS RELEASE

       

CASE#: 26A3003112

RANK/TROOPER FULL NAME:    Trooper Ryan Riegler                         

STATION:       Berlin Barracks              

CONTACT#:  802.229.9191

 

DATE/TIME:  04/18/2026 2200-0001 hours

INCIDENT LOCATION: VT RT 100, Waterbury, VT

 

DIRECTED PATROL

 

SUMMARY OF INCIDENT:

On the above date, Troopers from the Berlin Barracks conducted a directed patrol focusing on impaired driving. During this patrol, Troopers conducted 14 traffic stops for violations of Title 23.

 

 

 

*Please note:  court date and time are subject to change at the discretion of

the court. Please call the criminal court clerk to confirm arraignment time.

 

Trooper Ryan Riegler

Berlin Barracks

578 Paine Turnpike N.

Berlin, VT

802.229.9191

 

St. Johnsbury Barracks / DUI & Negligent Operation

VSP News Release-Incident

 

STATE OF VERMONT

DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY

VERMONT STATE POLICE

 

NEWS RELEASE - CRASH

       

CASE#: 26A4003973

RANK/TROOPER FULL NAME: Trooper Benjamin Goodwin                           

STATION: St. Johnsbury                 

CONTACT#: 802-748-3111

 

DATE/TIME: 04/18/26 approximately 9:19 PM

INCIDENT LOCATION: Interstate 91 South, Mile Marker 103, Newbury, VT

VIOLATION: DUI & Negligent Operation

 

VEHICLE #1

OPERATOR: Charles McFadden

AGE: 30
SEAT BELT? N/a

CITY, STATE OF RESIDENCE: Alpha, NJ

 

DESCRIPTION OF VEHICLE: Honda Motorcycle

DAMAGE TO VEHICLE: Moderate

 

INJURIES: Non-life threatening

WEATHER: Clear        

ROAD COND: Dry

 

SUMMARY OF INCIDENT:

 

On 04/18/2026 at approximately 9:19 PM, Troopers from the St. Johnsbury barracks were dispatched to a report of a one vehicle crash involving a motorcycle in the town of Newbury, VT. Upon arriving on scene the operator was being treated by EMS.  Investigation determined McFadden was under the influence of intoxicants at the time of operation and he was processed for DUI at Dartmouth Hitchcock Medical Center.  He was released with a citation to appear in Orange County Superior Court - Criminal Division.

 

COURT ACTION: Yes

COURT DATE/TIME: 06/24/26          

COURT: Orange

LODGED - LOCATION: N/A    

BAIL: N/A

MUG SHOT: NO

 

 

 

 

*Please note:  court date and time are subject to change at the discretion of

the court. Please call the criminal court clerk to confirm arraignment time.

 

 

RE: Traffic Alert - Vt Route 133 in the area 4441

Roadway is reopened.

 

From: Deslauriers, Katherine via DPS.VSPMedia <dps.vspmedia@list.vermont.gov>
Sent: Saturday, April 18, 2026 11:21 AM
To: DPS - Roadway Alert <DPS.RoadwayAlert@vermont.gov>
Subject: Traffic Alert - Vt Route 133 in the area 4441

 

EXTERNAL SENDER: Do not open attachments or click on links unless you recognize and trust the sender.

State of Vermont
Department of Public Safety
Vermont State Police
Rutland 

News Release – Highway / Traffic Notification
Vt Route 133 in the area 4441 has both lanes obstructed in the area of in the area of 4441 VT Route 133 due to a crash.

This incident is expected to last for 1-2 hours.  Specific details are not yet available, updates will be provided as appropriate.
 
Motorists should expect delays in the area or seek alternate routes.  Please drive carefully.

RE: Royalton Barracks /VT Arrest Warrant

STATE OF VERMONT

DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY

VERMONT STATE POLICE

 

NEWS RELEASE

             

CASE#: 26B2001788

Rank/Trooper Name: Sgt. Max Trenosky                       

STATION: Royalton                

CONTACT#: 802-234-9933

 

DATE/TIME: 04/18/2026 at approximately 1600 hours

LOCATION: Route 5, Hartland, VT

VIOLATION: Arrest on VT Warrant-Second Degree Agg. Domestic Assault, Reckless Endangerment, Resisting Arrest, Violation of Abuse Prevention

 

ACCUSED: David A. Thibodeau Sr.

AGE: 66

CITY, STATE OF RESIDENCE: Hartland, VT

 

SUMMARY OF INCIDENT:

On April 18^th, 2026, at approximately 1600 hours while investigating a citizen dispute on Route 5 in the town of Hartland, Troopers from the Royalton Barracks had received information regarding a witness to the dispute at this location had an active VT arrest warrant.  An investigation began into David A. Thibodeau Sr. and his active arrest warrant.  Further investigation showed that Thibodeau Sr. failed to appear on April 9, 2026, for Felony-2^nd degree, Agg. Domestic Assault, Reckless Endangerment, Resisting Arrest & Violation of Abuse Prevention Order.

 

Thibodeau Sr. was located outside a property at 273 RT. 5 in the town of Hartland and was taken into custody for the warrant. Thibodeau Sr. was then transported to Southern State Correctional Facility in Springfield, VT where he was held on $2500 cash or surety. Thibodeau Sr. was additionally issued a flash citation ordering Thibodeau Sr. to appear before the Windsor Superior County Criminal Court on April 20^th, 2026, at 1230 hours.

  

COURT ACTION: YES

COURT DATE: 04/20/2026 at 1230 hours             

COURT: Windsor Superior County Criminal Court

LODGED – LOCATION: Southern State Correctional Facility        

BAIL: $2500 Cash or Surety (VT-Warrant)

MUG SHOT: None

 

 

 

St. Johnsbury Barracks/ DUI

STATE OF VERMONT

DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY

VERMONT STATE POLICE

 

NEWS RELEASE

       

CASE#: 26A4003908

RANK/TROOPER FULL NAME:  Trooper James LeBlanc                      

STATION:  St. Johnsbury                   

CONTACT#: 802-748-3111

 

DATE/TIME: 4/17/2026 at 2001 hours

INCIDENT LOCATION: I 91 North Mile Marker 121.0

VIOLATION: DUI

 

ACCUSED: Paul Gaughan                           

AGE: 28

CITY, STATE OF RESIDENCE: Worcester, MA

 

SUMMARY OF INCIDENT: On 4/17/2026, at approximately 2001 hours, Troopers observed a vehicle commit multiple motor vehicle violations on Interstate 91 North at Mile Marker 121.0. Troopers initiated a traffic stop and investigation revealed Gaughan operated a motor vehicle under the influence of alcohol. Gaughan was taken into custody for processing and released on citation.

 

COURT ACTION: Yes

COURT DATE/TIME: 5/4/2026 at 0830 hours           

COURT: Caledonia

LODGED - LOCATION:  N/A    

BAIL: N/A

MUG SHOT: Attached

 

 

*Please note:  court date and time are subject to change at the discretion of

the court. Please call the criminal court clerk to confirm arraignment time.

 

Trooper James LeBlanc

Vermont State Police – St. Johnsbury

1068 US Rt 5 #1

St. Johnsbury, VT 05819

(802)-748-3111

 

 

Traffic Alert - Vt Route 133 in the area 4441

State of Vermont
Department of Public Safety
Vermont State Police
Rutland 

News Release – Highway / Traffic Notification
Vt Route 133 in the area 4441 has both lanes obstructed in the area of in the area of 4441 VT Route 133 due to a crash.

This incident is expected to last for 1-2 hours.  Specific details are not yet available, updates will be provided as appropriate.
 
Motorists should expect delays in the area or seek alternate routes.  Please drive carefully.

MV Crash / Rutland Barracks

STATE OF VERMONT

DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY

VERMONT STATE POLICE

 

NEWS RELEASE

MOTOR VEHICLE CRASH

 

CASE#: 26B4003031                        

RANK / TROOPER FULL NAME: Trooper Hayley Mears

STATION: Rutland                           

CONTACT#: (802) 773-9101

 

DATE/TIME: On April 18^th, 2026, at approximately 1100 hours

STREET: VT RT 133

TOWN: Ira, VT

LANDMARK AND/OR CROSS STREETS: 4441 VT RT 133

INTERSTATE MILE MARKER: N/A

WEATHER: Sunny

ROAD CONDITIONS: Clear, dry

 

VEHICLE #1

OPERATOR: Albert Burton

AGE: 78

SEAT BELT? Yes

CITY, STATE OF RESIDENCE: Wells, VT

 

PASSENGER: Janice Burton

AGE: 77

SEAT BELT?: Yes

CITY, STATE OF RESIDENCE: Wells, VT

 

VEHICLE YEAR: 2018

VEHICLE MAKE: GMC

VEHICLE MODEL: Sierra

DAMAGE TO VEHICLE #1: Significant

INJURIES: Minor

HOSPITAL: Rutland Regional Medical Center

 

SUMMARY OF CRASH:

On 4/18/2026, at approximately 1100 hours, Troopers from the Vermont State Police - Rutland Barracks were notified of a single-vehicle crash on Route 133 in Ira.

Through investigation, it was revealed that Operator #1 (Burton) was operating vehicle #1, traveling north on Route 133. Operator #1 (Burton) failed to maintain his lane of travel. Vehicle #1 exited the roadway and collided with a tree. Operator #1 (Burton) sustained minor injury from the crash.

 

The Vermont State Police were assisted by Ira Fire Department & Rutland Regional Ambulance Service.

 

Vermont Civil Violation Complaint: Pending

 

 

Derby Barracks / DUI Refusal

VSP News Release-Incident

 

STATE OF VERMONT

DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY

VERMONT STATE POLICE

 

NEWS RELEASE

       

CASE#:26A5002042

RANK/TROOPER FULL NAME: Trooper Jacob Shores                         

STATION: Derby                     

CONTACT#: 802-334-8881

 

DATE/TIME: 04/18/2026 @ 0322 Hours

INCIDENT LOCATION: I 91 S Derby Line Point of Entry

VIOLATION: DUI REFUSAL

 

ACCUSED: Justin Wilson                                              

AGE: 44

CITY, STATE OF RESIDENCE: Blue Ridge, GA

 

SUMMARY OF INCIDENT: On 04/18/2026 at approximately 0322 hours Troopers from the Derby Barracks were notified of a vehicle operated by Jason Wilson had attempted to enter the U.S. at the Derby Line Point of Entry and Border Patrol advised he appeared to be under the influence of drugs or alcohol. Troopers identified multiple indicators of impairment and Wilson was placed under arrest. Newport Police Department assisted Troopers from the Derby Barracks during processing. Wilson was issued a criminal citation to appear in Orleans County Superior Court for the charge of DUI refusal. 

 

 

COURT ACTION: Y

COURT DATE/TIME: 05/05/2026 @ 0830 Hours         

COURT: Orleans County Superior Court

LODGED - LOCATION: N/A   

BAIL: N/A

MUG SHOT: IMAGE INCLUDED

 

 

 

 

*Please note:  court date and time are subject to change at the discretion of

the court. Please call the criminal court clerk to confirm arraignment time.

 

 

Trooper Jacob Shores

Vermont State Police

Troop A – Derby Barracks

35 Crawford Road

Derby, Vermont 05829

Jacob.Shores@vermont.gov

(802)-334-8881

 

Royalton Barracks / 1st Degree Aggravated Domestic Assault

 

STATE OF VERMONT

DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY

VERMONT STATE POLICE

NEWS RELEASE

       

CASE#: 26B2001785

RANK/TROOPER NAME: Trooper Connery                          

STATION: Royalton                  

CONTACT#: (802)234-9933

DATE: April 18, 2026

INCIDENT LOCATION: Hidden Glen Road, Bethel, VT

VIOLATION: First Degree Aggravated Domestic Assault

ACCUSED: Karen L. Kill                                         

AGE: 38

CITY, STATE OF RESIDENCE: Bethel, Vermont

VICTIM: (The Vermont State Police does not release the names of victims of

sexual assault or domestic violence.)

SUMMARY OF INCIDENT:

On April 18th, 2026, at approximately 1056 hours, the Vermont State Police responded to a report of an assault regarding domestic issues at a residence on Hidden Glen Road in the town of Bethel. Further investigation resulted in Karen L. Kill (38) being placed under arrest for 1st Degree Aggravated Domestic Assault. Karen L. Kill (38) was transported to the Vermont State Police Royalton Barracks and ordered held without bail, also provided a Criminal Citation to appear in the Windsor County Superior Court, Criminal Division, on April 20th, 2026, at 1230 hours.

COURT ACTION: Yes

COURT DATE/TIME: April 20th, 2026, at 1230 hours            

COURT: Windsor County Superior Court, Criminal Division

LODGED - LOCATION: Southern State Correctional

BAIL: Held w/out bail

MUG SHOT: Included

St. Johnsbury Barracks / Request for Public Assistance

VSP News Release-Incident

 

STATE OF VERMONT

DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY

VERMONT STATE POLICE

 

NEWS RELEASE

       

CASE#: 26A4003939

RANK/TROOPER FULL NAME: Trooper Adam Aremburg                             

STATION: St. Johnsbury                    

CONTACT#: 802-748-3111

 

DATE/TIME: 04/18/2026 at approximately 1016 hours

INCIDENT LOCATION: I-91 Northbound near MM113.4, Ryegate

VIOLATION: Negligent Operation

 

ACCUSED: Unknown                                       

AGE:

CITY, STATE OF RESIDENCE:

 

 

SUMMARY OF INCIDENT:

 

On April 18, 2026, at approximately 10:16 a.m., Troopers were monitoring traffic on Interstate 91 northbound in Ryegate near mile marker 113.4 when two vehicles were observed traveling at a high rate of speed.

 

Troopers were able to identify one of the operators, who was actively reporting the incident to authorities. The preliminary investigation revealed that the incident appeared to be road rage related after one operator passed the other on the interstate.

 

Troopers are attempting to identify the second operator, who was driving a dark-colored Honda Ridgeline. The operator is described as a caucasian male with short hair and glasses. Troopers were also advised that a dog, believed to be a German Shepherd, was inside the vehicle.

 

Anyone with information is asked to contact Trooper Aremburg at the St. Johnsbury Barracks.

 

Anonymous tips may be submitted by texting the keyword VTIPS to 274637 (CRIMES) or online at: https://cityprotect.com/forms/state.vt.us/anonymous

 

 

Trooper Adam Aremburg

VT State Police – St. Johnsbury

1068 US Route 5, Suite 1

St. Johnsbury, VT 05819

802.748.3111

 

St. Albans Barracks / Arrest on Warrant

STATE OF VERMONT

DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY

VERMONT STATE POLICE

 

NEWS RELEASE

             

CASE#: 26A2002406

TROOPER:  Adam Martin                           

STATION: St Albans Barracks                   

CONTACT#: 802-524-5993

 

DATE/TIME: 04/17/2026 at approximately 1909 hours

LOCATION: Perley Road Enosburg, VT

VIOLATION: Arrest on Warrant

 

ACCUSED: Eric Benware

AGE: 43

CITY, STATE OF RESIDENCE: Richford, VT

 

SUMMARY OF INCIDENT:

 

On April 17^th, 2026, at approximately 1909 hours while conducting patrol in the Town of Enosburg, Troopers from the St. Albans Barracks had received information regarding the whereabouts of Eric Benware (43) of Richford, VT. Benware was known to have an active warrant for his arrest.

 

Benware was located at an address on Perley Road in the Town of Enosburg and was taken into custody for the warrant. Benware was then transported to Northwest State Correctional Facility in the Town of St. Albans where he was held on $200 bail. Benware was additionally issued a flash citation ordering Benware to appear before the Franklin County Criminal Court on April 20^th, 2026, at 1300 hours.

 

The active warrant contained the charges of:

 

13 VSA 1026(a)(1) Misdemeanor 1 DISORDERLY CONDUCT- FIGHT ETC

 

COURT ACTION: YES

COURT DATE: 04/20/2026 at 1300 hours             

COURT: Franklin County Criminal Court

LODGED – LOCATION: Northwest State Correctional Facility        

BAIL: $200

MUG SHOT: None

 

 

Trooper Adam Martin (221)

Vermont State Police

St. Albans Barracks

(802)524-5993

Adam.martin@vermont.gov

 

UPDATE: New Haven Barracks / Missing Person

Mr. Montagne was located safely.

---

From: Demick, Taylor via DPS.VSPMedia <dps.vspmedia@list.vermont.gov>
Sent: Thursday, April 16, 2026 2:56 PM
To: DPS - VSP Media <DPS.VSPMedia@list.vermont.gov>
Subject: New Haven Barracks / Missing Person

 

EXTERNAL SENDER: Do not open attachments or click on links unless you recognize and trust the sender.

VSP News Release - Missing Person

 

STATE OF VERMONT

DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY

VERMONT STATE POLICE

 

NEWS RELEASE

       

CASE#: 26B5001514

RANK/TROOPER FULL NAME: Trooper Taylor Demick

STATION: New Haven Barracks               

CONTACT#: 802-388-4919

 

DATE/TIME: April 16^th, 2026, at 1315 hours

INCIDENT LOCATION: Vermont Route 116 / Vermont Route 17, Bristol, VT

MISSING PERSON

 

MISSING: Timothy J. Montagne

AGE: 41

CITY, STATE OF RESIDENCE: Bristol, Vermont

 

 

SUMMARY OF INCIDENT: On April 16^th, 2026, at approximately 1315 hours, The Vermont State Police – New Haven Barracks were notified of a missing person in the Town of Bristol, VT. Preliminary investigation revealed Timothy J. Montagne (41) was reportedly last seen on April 15^th , 2026, at approximately 1530 hours in the area of Vermont Route 116  and Vermont Route 17 in the Town of Bristol. The incident does not appear suspicious, though there are concerns for Montagne’s welfare.

 

A photograph of Timothy J. Montagne is attached to this press release. Montagne is approximately 5'10" tall, 155 lbs, bald, with a brown/grey beard, and hazel eyes. He was last seen wearing a black balaclava, a black long-sleeve shirt, a blue coat, and carrying a black backpack along with a red bag. He was last seen riding a grey mountain bike.

 

Anyone with information on Timothy J. Montagne’s whereabouts is asked to contact the Vermont State Police – New Haven Barracks at 802-388-4919.

 

Rutland Barracks/ Stalking

VSP News Release-Incident

 

STATE OF VERMONT

DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY

VERMONT STATE POLICE

 

NEWS RELEASE

       

CASE#: 26B4002294

RANK/TROOPER FULL NAME: Trooper Jonathan Hall

STATION: Rutland                    

CONTACT#: (802) 773-9101

 

DATE/TIME: November 2025 - March 2026

INCIDENT LOCATION: Rutland County, Vermont

VIOLATION: Stalking

 

ACCUSED: Peter Pfenning

AGE: 63

CITY, STATE OF RESIDENCE: Castleton, Vermont

 

VICTIM: (The Vermont State Police does not release the names of victims of

sexual assault or domestic violence.)

 

 

SUMMARY OF INCIDENT: On Friday, March 25, 2026, at approximately 1640 hours, Vermont State Police – Rutland Barracks responded to a report of stalking. Troopers learned that a person believed that Peter Pfenning, 63, of Castleton, had intentionally followed them, attempting to initiate contact multiple times on multiple occasions.

 

The investigation revealed that Pfenning had followed, gathered personal information, and attempted to contact through multiple sources. The investigation further revealed a pattern of stalking.

 

On April 16, 2026, at approximately 1130 hours, Pfenning was issued a citation and ordered to appear in Vermont Superior Court - Rutland Criminal Division on Friday, April 17, 2026. Pfenning is being held without bail on a probation violation stemming from this investigation.

 

 

COURT ACTION: Yes

COURT DATE/TIME: April 17, 2026, 1230 hours           

COURT: Vermont Superior Court - Rutland Criminal Division

LODGED - LOCATION: Marble Valley Regional Correctional Facility     

BAIL:

MUG SHOT: Attached

 

 

 

 

*Please note:  court date and time are subject to change at the discretion of

the court. Please call the criminal court c

 

 

B Troop / DLS Criminal Incidents

STATE OF VERMONT

DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY

VERMONT STATE POLICE 

NEWS RELEASE – DLS INCIDENTS 

SUMMARY OF INCIDENT:

For the week of Wednesday, April 8, 2026, through Tuesday, April 14, 2026, the troopers of B Troop cited the following individuals on suspicion of driving with a criminally suspended license: 

 

Caroline Arpe, 49, of Brattleboro Vermont was stopped by Trooper Zachary Kunow on I-91 in Guilford on April 12, 2026.  Arpe is cited to appear at the Superior Court Windham of Windham County on May 26, 2026.

 

Jacob Ackert, 22, of Rutland City Vermont was stopped by Trooper Bruce Cleaver on US Route 4 in Castleton on April 14, 2026.  Ackert is cited to appear at the Superior Court Rutland County on June 1, 2026.

 

Tanya Fisher, 40, of Westminster Vermont was stopped by Trooper Zachary Kunow on I-91 in Westminster on April 14, 2026.  Fisher is cited to appear at the Superior Court Windham County on June 6, 2026.

 

B Troop consists of the Vermont State Police barracks in New Haven, Royalton, Rutland, Shaftsbury, and Westminster.

 

Vermont State Police releases after-action report, video footage from March 11 incident in South Burlington

 

STATE OF VERMONT

DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY

VERMONT STATE POLICE

 

Vermont State Police releases after-action report, video footage from March 11 incident in South Burlington

 

WATERBURY, Vermont (Friday, April 17, 2026) — The Vermont State Police is releasing material connected to the March 11, 2026, federal police action on Dorset Street in South Burlington, to which state troopers were later called to assist with public safety.

 

Today’s release includes a complete after-action report, about 60 hours of video footage from troopers’ body-worn cameras, and a statement from Public Safety Commissioner Jennifer Morrison.

 

These materials are available for review and download from the Vermont State Police’s Dropbox account. This link will remain active for 90 days; anyone who needs access to these materials after three months should download the files before the link expires.

 

The state police will have no further comment on this matter.

 

- 30 -

Berlin Barracks / DUI

VSP News Release-Incident

STATE OF VERMONT

DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY

VERMONT STATE POLICE

 

NEWS RELEASE

       

CASE#: 26A3003040

RANK/TROOPER NAME: Trooper Alexis Marciniak                  

STATION: Berlin Barracks

CONTACT#: 802-229-9191

 

DATE/TIME: 04/17/2026 at 11:47 AM

INCIDENT LOCATION: Interstate 89 North, Mile Marker 65, Waterbury, Vermont

VIOLATION: Driving Under the Influence

 

ACCUSED: Scott A. Mumley

AGE: 61

CITY, STATE OF RESIDENCE: St. Albans, Vermont

 

SUMMARY OF INCIDENT: On 04/17/2026, at approximately 11:47 AM, the Vermont State Police received a report of a two-vehicle crash at the rest area located on Interstate 89 North near Mile Marker 65 in the Town of Waterbury, Vermont. Troopers from the Berlin Barracks responded to the scene, and subsequent investigation revealed that 61-year-old Scott A. Mumley was operating his motor vehicle while impaired by alcohol. Mumley was arrested for Driving Under the Influence then transported to the Berlin Barracks for processing. He was later released with a criminal citation to appear in Vermont Superior Court, Washington Unit, Criminal Division on 05/07/2026, at 8:30 AM, to answer to the above charge.

 

COURT ACTION: Y

COURT DATE/TIME: 05/07/2026 at 8:30 AM            

COURT: Vermont Superior Court, Washington Unit, Criminal Division

LODGED - LOCATION: N

BAIL: N

MUG SHOT: Y

 

*Please note: Court date and time are subject to change at the discretion of the court. Please call the criminal court clerk to confirm arraignment time.

Shaftsbury Barracks / Multiple Charges

VSP News Release-Incident

 

STATE OF VERMONT

DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY

VERMONT STATE POLICE

 

NEWS RELEASE

       

CASE#: 26B3001820

RANK/TROOPER FULL NAME: Trooper Colin Shepley                            

STATION: Shaftsbury Barracks                    

CONTACT#: 802-442-5421

 

DATE/TIME: 04/17/2026 at 0547 hours.

INCIDENT LOCATION: White Creek Road Shaftsbury, VT

VIOLATION: Attempted Burglary, Attempted Unlawful Trespass into a Dwelling, Unlawful Mischief, Receiving Stolen Property, Impeding Public Officers.

 

ACCUSED: Robert T. Metcalfe                                               

AGE: 32

CITY, STATE OF RESIDENCE: Londonderry, VT

 

VICTIM: Nancy Myers

AGE: 73

CITY, STATE OF RESIDENCE: Shaftsbury, VT

 

SUMMARY OF INCIDENT: On the above date and time, Vermont State Police were dispatched to an active attempted burglary at a residence on White Creek Road in the Town of Shaftsbury. With the assistance of the Bennington Police Department, the suspect, Robert T. Metcalfe was located and taken into custody a short distance away. Investigation revealed that Metcalfe had stolen a vehicle in Hoosick Falls, NY during the overnight hours and left it abandoned on a section of railroad tracks in Shaftsbury, VT. Metcalfe then attempted to break into the residence on White Creek Road before being taken into custody.

 

After being taken into custody and at the Southwestern Vermont Medical Center, Metcalfe approached a State Trooper and attempted to retrieve their department issued holstered sidearm before being brought under control. Metcalfe was later transported to Marble Valley Correctional Center for lack of $10,000 bail and will be arraigned in Vermont Superior Court Bennington Criminal Division on 04/20/2026 at 1230 hours.

 

 

COURT ACTION: Yes

COURT DATE/TIME: 04/20/2026 at 1230 hours.            

COURT: Vermont Superior Court Bennington Criminal Division

LODGED - LOCATION: Marble Valley Correctional Center  

BAIL: $10,000

MUG SHOT: INCLUDED

 

 

*Please note:  court date and time are subject to change at the discretion of

the court. Please call the criminal court clerk to confirm arraignment time.

 

Trooper Colin Shepley

Vermont State Police Shaftsbury

96 Airport Road Shaftsbury, VT 05262

802-442-5421